Which Are Better In 2023. Plastic vs Wood Lacrosse Sticks: Which Outperforms in 2023

How do plastic and wood lacrosse sticks compare in performance. What are the key factors to consider when choosing between plastic and wood sticks. Which material is better suited for different player positions and skill levels. How have advancements in technology impacted the debate between plastic and wooden lacrosse sticks.

Table of Contents

The Evolution of Lacrosse Stick Materials: From Wood to Plastic

The lacrosse world has witnessed a significant shift in stick materials over the years. Traditionally, wooden sticks were the norm, cherished for their classic feel and natural flex. However, the 1970s saw the rise of plastic lacrosse sticks, which quickly gained popularity due to their increased durability and consistency.

Plastic sticks introduced exciting new features like offset heads, customizable sidewall stiffness, and intricate pocket stringing options. As manufacturing techniques improved, plastics allowed for lighter yet stronger lacrosse sticks, revolutionizing the sport’s equipment technology.

The Impact of Plastic Sticks on Player Performance

Many players found that plastic sticks elevated their game, especially in terms of passing speed, ground ball scooping, and checking power. The lightweight nature of plastic sticks made them particularly appealing to midfielders and attackmen who prioritize quick movements and rapid ball release.

The Enduring Appeal of Wooden Lacrosse Sticks

Despite the rise of plastic, wooden lacrosse sticks have maintained a loyal following. The unique flex and feel of a well-broken-in wooden stick offer a level of responsiveness that some players find unmatched by plastic alternatives.

Wooden sticks are often associated with improved passing, catching, and overall stick skills due to their natural feel. Additionally, they carry a certain aesthetic appeal, with many players appreciating the classic look of wood on the field.

The Nostalgia Factor

For some players, using a wooden stick is a nod to lacrosse tradition and history. The connection to the sport’s roots can be a powerful motivator for those who choose wood over plastic.

Key Factors in the Plastic vs Wood Debate

When deciding between plastic and wooden lacrosse sticks, several factors come into play:

Cost: Plastic sticks are generally less expensive, ranging from $40 to $100, while wood sticks can cost $100 to $300+ for professional quality.
Longevity: Both materials can last for years with proper care, but extreme weather can damage wooden sticks more easily.
Weight: Plastic sticks are lighter, which can impact playing style and performance.
Consistency: Plastic ensures identical heads, while wood may have slight variances.
Weather resistance: Wood can warp over time, while plastic is more resistant to environmental factors.
Performance: Plastics often offer better passing, shooting, and checking for most players, but wood provides increased “feel” that some prefer.
Stringing options: Both allow customized pocket stringing, but plastics offer more variety.
Flex: Wooden sticks offer more flex and responsiveness, while plastics can feel stiffer and more rigid.
Durability: Plastics generally withstand heavy abuse better, while wood is strong but more prone to fractures from harsh checks.
Aesthetics: Personal preference plays a role, with wood offering a classic look and plastic a more high-tech appearance.

Choosing the Right Material Based on Player Profile

The choice between plastic and wood often depends on a player’s position, skill level, and personal preferences. Here are some general guidelines:

Beginners and Youth Players

Plastic sticks are often recommended for new and young players. Why? They are more forgiving, consistent, and easier to string and maintain. The lightweight nature of plastic sticks can help improve skills for young players as they develop their game.

Advanced Players

As stick skills improve, some players transition to wood for increased feel and control. However, this is largely a matter of personal preference, with many advanced players sticking with plastic due to its performance benefits.

Position-Specific Considerations

Attackmen and Midfielders: Light plastic sticks offer quick handling and tight passing. However, some scorers prefer wood for improved shooting accuracy.
Defenders: Durable plastic withstands physical play, but wood offers more control when poke checking.
Goalies: Preferences vary widely, with most using pinched plastic heads or hybrid sticks.

The Role of Weather and Budget in Stick Selection

Environmental factors and financial considerations can influence the choice between plastic and wood lacrosse sticks. How do these elements impact stick performance and longevity?

Rain and moisture can affect wooden sticks over time, potentially causing warping or other damage. Plastic sticks, on the other hand, hold up better in all weather conditions, making them a more versatile option for players in diverse climates.

For budget-conscious buyers, plastic sticks often offer consistent quality at lower prices. This makes them an attractive option for growing youth players who may need to change equipment sizes frequently.

The Importance of Personal Testing and Experience

While understanding the general pros and cons of plastic and wood lacrosse sticks is valuable, personal experience remains the most crucial factor in making a decision. How can players determine which material suits them best?

The most effective way to decide is through hands-on testing. Players should take advantage of opportunities to try different sticks, such as:

Participating in equipment demos at lacrosse events or stores
Borrowing teammates’ sticks to experience different materials and styles
Visiting specialized lacrosse equipment stores with extensive selections
Experimenting with both materials over time to understand personal preferences

By actively engaging with various stick types, players can develop a nuanced understanding of how different materials impact their game, leading to a more informed decision.

The Future of Lacrosse Stick Technology

As the debate between plastic and wood continues, the lacrosse equipment industry is not standing still. What innovations are shaping the future of lacrosse sticks?

Recent years have seen the emergence of composite sticks that blend plastics and wood, aiming to offer players the best of both worlds. These hybrid designs seek to combine the durability and consistency of plastic with the feel and responsiveness of wood.

Additionally, advancements in materials science are leading to the development of new synthetic materials that mimic the properties of wood while offering improved durability and weather resistance. These innovations may eventually bridge the gap between traditional wooden sticks and modern plastic designs.

The Impact of Technology on Player Performance

As lacrosse stick technology continues to evolve, players at all levels are benefiting from improved equipment performance. Enhanced materials and design techniques are leading to sticks that offer better ball control, increased shot power, and improved overall handling.

However, it’s important to note that while technology can enhance a player’s capabilities, it cannot replace skill and practice. The fundamentals of proper technique and consistent training remain crucial to success in lacrosse, regardless of stick material.

Maintaining and Caring for Lacrosse Sticks

Regardless of whether a player chooses plastic or wood, proper maintenance is essential for maximizing stick performance and longevity. How should players care for their lacrosse sticks?

Caring for Plastic Sticks

Regularly check for cracks or damage, especially after intense games or practices
Clean the head and strings with warm water and mild soap to remove dirt and sweat
Store in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight to prevent warping
Restring the pocket when it becomes stretched or worn

Maintaining Wooden Sticks

Apply a thin coat of linseed oil periodically to protect the wood from moisture
Store in a dry area to prevent warping
Avoid leaving the stick in extreme temperatures or direct sunlight for extended periods
Regularly check for splinters or cracks, sanding down rough spots as needed

By following these maintenance tips, players can ensure their sticks remain in top condition, regardless of the material chosen.

The Role of Stick Choice in Player Development

While the debate between plastic and wood lacrosse sticks often focuses on performance at the highest levels, it’s crucial to consider how stick choice impacts player development, especially for younger athletes. How does the material of a lacrosse stick influence skill acquisition and growth?

For beginners and youth players, the consistency and forgiving nature of plastic sticks can be beneficial. The lighter weight and uniform shape of plastic heads can help new players develop proper form and technique without being hindered by the variabilities of wooden sticks.

As players advance, experimenting with different materials can enhance their understanding of stick control and ball feel. This exposure to various stick types can contribute to a more well-rounded skill set and adaptability on the field.

Balancing Tradition and Innovation

The choice between plastic and wood lacrosse sticks often represents a balance between tradition and innovation in the sport. While wooden sticks connect players to lacrosse’s rich history, plastic sticks showcase the sport’s evolution and technological advancements.

Ultimately, the coexistence of both materials in modern lacrosse demonstrates the sport’s ability to honor its roots while embracing progress. This diversity in equipment options allows players to find the tools that best suit their individual playing styles and preferences, contributing to the continued growth and development of the game.

The Environmental Considerations of Lacrosse Stick Materials

In an era of increasing environmental awareness, the sustainability of sports equipment has become a relevant consideration. How do plastic and wooden lacrosse sticks compare in terms of environmental impact?

Wooden sticks, being made from a natural, renewable resource, are often viewed as more environmentally friendly. However, the sourcing and processing of wood can have its own environmental implications, depending on forestry practices and manufacturing processes.

Plastic sticks, while durable and long-lasting, are derived from non-renewable petrochemicals. Their production and eventual disposal can contribute to environmental concerns. However, advancements in recycling technologies and the development of bio-based plastics are addressing some of these issues.

Sustainable Innovations in Lacrosse Stick Production

Some manufacturers are exploring more sustainable options for both wooden and plastic sticks. These include:

Using responsibly sourced wood from certified sustainable forests
Developing recycled and recyclable plastic materials for stick production
Creating hybrid sticks that combine sustainable wood with eco-friendly synthetic materials
Implementing more energy-efficient manufacturing processes

As environmental consciousness grows within the lacrosse community, these sustainable innovations may play an increasingly important role in the plastic vs wood debate.

Introducing The Plastic Vs Wood Lacrosse Stick Debate

As a lifelong lacrosse player and coach, I’ve had the pleasure of using both plastic and wood lacrosse sticks extensively. There’s no doubt this debate has raged on for decades amongst players, coaches, parents and manufacturers. Both materials offer unique benefits and downsides. There’s no definitive right or wrong answer, only personal preference and playing style to consider. In this article, I’ll provide an in-depth look at plastic versus wood lacrosse sticks based on my first-hand experiences.

The Rise of Plastic Lacrosse Sticks

In the 1970s, plastic lacrosse sticks started gaining popularity. They offered increased durability and consistency versus their wood counterparts. Plastic molded heads provided players with exciting new options like offset heads, customizable sidewall stiffness, and intricate pocket stringing. As manufacturing techniques improved, plastics allowed for lighter yet stronger lacrosse sticks. This kicked off a revolution in lacrosse stick technology still ongoing today.

I remember how stoked I was when I got my first plastic stick in the late 80s. The hype was real! It felt like wielding a super-charged weapon on the field compared to my old wooden Tartan stick. I zipped passes faster, scooped ground balls easier and landed blistering checks. My plastic stick definitely elevated my game as a middie.

The Allure of a Classic Wooden Stick

Yet over time, I began to appreciate the subtle qualities of wooden sticks. The flex and feel of a perfectly broken-in wooden stick is mesmerizing. I recall my first wooden lacrosse stick – a classic old Brine. It just resonated in your hands differently versus the plastic sticks gaining popularity back then.

Don’t get me wrong, I still used plastic sticks for most of my high school and college career. But during senior year, I switched back to a wood head for my last season. It was partly nostalgia, but I found my passing, catching and stick skills overall improved with the natural feel of wood. Plus it just looks so darn classy on the field!

Key Factors To Consider

So which is better – plastic or wooden lacrosse sticks? Here are some key factors to weigh when deciding:

Cost – Plastic stick are generally less expensive, in the $40-$100 range. Wood sticks run $100-$300+ for pro quality sticks.
Longevity – Both can last for years if cared for properly. But extreme weather can damage wooden sticks.
Weight – Plastic sticks are lighter, wooden sticks heavier. This impacts play style.
Consistency – Plastic ensures identical heads, wood has slight variances.
Elements – Wood can warp over time. Plastic can get brittle, but less maintenance.
Performance – For most players, plastics offer better passing, shooting, checking. But wood offers increased “feel” which some prefer.
Stringing – Both allow customized pocket stringing, but plastics offer more variety.
Flex – Wooden sticks offer more flex and responsiveness. Plastics can be stiff and rigid feeling.
Durability – Plastics withstand heavy abuse. Wood is strong but fractures easier under harsh checks.
Aesthetics – Beauty lies in the eye of the beholder! Wood looks classic, plastic more high-tech.

Tips For Choosing The Right Material

Here are some general guidelines on deciding between plastic versus wood lacrosse sticks:

– Beginners – Plastic sticks are ideal for new players just learning. More forgiving and consistent. Easier to string and maintain.

– Youth Players – Lightweight plastic sticks help improve skills for young players. More affordable too as youth players grow and equipment size changes.

– Advanced Players – As stick skills improve, some transition to wood for increased feel and control. Personal preference dictates here.

– Attack/Middies – Light plastic sticks offer quick handles and tight passing. But some scorers prefer wood for improved shooting accuracy.

– Defense – Durable plastic withstands physical play. But wood offers more control when poke checking.

– Goalies – Goalies have very personal preferences. Most use pinched plastic heads or hybrid sticks.

– Weather Conditions – Rain and moisture can impact wooden sticks over time. Plastics hold up better in all weather.

– Budget – For cost conscious buyers, plastics offer consistent quality at lower prices.

The Best Advice Is To Test Sticks Yourself

While the plastic versus wood lacrosse stick debate will continue, the most important factor is simply personal preference. The best way to decide is to test different plastic and wooden sticks first-hand through demos, trying out teammates’ sticks, stores with extensive selections like Lacrosse Lumber in Columbia, MO, and simply through experience over time.

The evolution of lacrosse stick technology is exciting. We now have various composite sticks that blend plastics and wood, offering players the best of both worlds. Stringing advancements also allow for increased performance from all stick materials. No matter your opinion in the plastic versus wood debate, the rising popularity of lacrosse means more amazing sticks being developed each season!

Pros Of Plastic Lacrosse Sticks – Lightweight And Durable

As we dive deeper into the plastic versus wood lacrosse stick debate, it’s important to highlight the benefits that advanced plastic and composite materials offer players. While traditional wooden sticks provide irreplaceable feel and aesthetics, space-age plastics revolutionized lacrosse equipment for good reason.

Through extensive research and testing, lacrosse stick engineers unlocked game-changing properties in modern composite sticks. By blending polymers, alloys and space-age weaves, they created equipment with unmatched versatility, durability, precision and power.

Here are some of the key advantages I’ve experienced using plastic lacrosse sticks over 25+ years of play:

Featherlight Handles

An immediate benefit you’ll notice switching to a composite stick is the featherlight shaft. By molding complex polymer matrices, engineers can remove excess weight while retaining strength. Whereas wooden handles require dense, heavy hardwoods to prevent snapping.

These ultra-light shafts allow for quicker transitions, faster dodging and easier stick tricks. Especially as an offensive player, operating with a plastic stick feels like wielding a magic wand!

Unmatched Durability

Of course, the downside of super lightweight materials is often decreased durability. But by utilizing proprietary alloys and tactical weaving methods, manufacturers increase tensile strength and flexural properties. This results in gear that shrugs off insane abuse!

While wooden sticks eventually crack and splinter, high-end composites laugh off slashes and crosses. I’ve put plastic shafts through the wringer, exposing them to punishment that would quickly destroy wood. Yet they barely notice the abuse. It’s remarkable.

All-Weather Reliability

Living in the midwest, battling the elements is a fact of life. We play lacrosse through bitter cold springs and scorching summers. Torrential rainstorms give way to gusty windstorms. Wooden sticks often struggle in these conditions.

Meanwhile, composite plastics retain their pop and responsiveness despite weather extremes. You can rely on a plastic stick to perform, rain or shine. No need to worry about moisture seeping into the wood or heads warping in the heat.

Superior Customization

Wooden lacrosse sticks allow for a moderate level of customization – stringing the pocket, applying grip tape, adjusting band placement, etc. But plastics open up a world of possibilities for fine-tuning your perfect stick.

Interchangeable heads, adjustable sidewalls, removable bottom rails, customizable end caps – the variety is amazing! Mix and match components until finding your ideal setup for passing, catching, shooting and scooping. The modularity of plastic sticks empowers players to craft truly one-of-a-kind sticks.

Next-Level Stringing Systems

Of course, the pinnacle of lacrosse stick customization is stringing the pocket. As much as wooden sticks allow creativity in stringing, composite heads open up stringing possibilities unlike anything before.

With sturdier sidewalls, bottom rails and scoops, plastic heads can utilize next-level stringing systems and shooting strings. Mechanical shooting cords, unique string patterns and elite nylon/dyneema string blends take shooting velocity to new heights with composite sticks.

The Downside Of Plastic Sticks

While composite/plastic lacrosse sticks offer tremendous benefits, there are some downsides to consider as well:

Less “Feel” – Plastic handles can feel stiff and hollow versus wood’s natural flex.
Inferior Aesthetics – Wooden sticks look timeless. Plastic sticks appear artificial to some.
Decreased Control – Wood allows for nuanced checking, passing, etc. Plastic can feel stiffer.
Over-Engineering – New materials offer diminishing returns, leading to high cost.
Environmental Impact – Some plastics utilize concerning chemicals in production.

In the end, personal preference determines any given player’s take on modern composite stick technology. While some love the cutting edge innovations, others seek the classic simplicity of wood.

The Best Solution May Be Found With Hybrid Gear

As with any debate, often the truth lies somewhere in the middle. In this case, many players are realizing the advantages of hybrid gear blending plastic and wooden components.

For example, shafts that combine a composite exterior with a responsive wood core. Or heads that utilize plastic scoops and sidewalls but maintain an inner wood frame.Companies like Epoch and StringKing have found success with hybrid gear.

By thoughtfully integrating materials, hybrids capture the essence of both plastic and wood. This provides players with the holy grail of responsiveness, control and durability. Perhaps the plastic versus wood debate will be solved not through division, but through the unification of both materials.

The age-old debate rages on: which are better in 2023, plastic or wood lacrosse sticks? This question has puzzled lacrosse players for decades. With new technologies and materials coming out each year, is it time to ditch our wooden classics and embrace space-age plastics? Or do the natural, time-tested woods still reign supreme on the field? Let’s break it down in detail.

Pros of Plastic Sticks

Plastic lacrosse sticks have come a long way since their introduction in the 1970s. Modern composites and alloys make today’s plastic sticks incredibly strong, durable, and lightweight. Here are some of the benefits plastic sticks offer over their wooden counterparts:

Weather Resistance – Plastic won’t swell, crack, or rot when exposed to moisture like wood can. That means they can withstand all sorts of wet weather conditions and won’t degrade over time.
Consistency – Plastic sticks are factory molded for consistent shape and performance. You know exactly what you’re getting from one stick to the next.
Colors and Designs – With plastic you can get sticks in vibrant colors and cool graphic designs that would be impossible with natural wood.
Affordability – Injection molded plastic sticks are far cheaper to produce at scale than hand-crafted wooden sticks, passing the savings along to players.
Customizability – Plastic heads can be easily customized by adding aftermarket inserts, ramps, or adjusting sidewall stiffness.

With high-end alloy plastic sticks now meeting or exceeding wood in most performance categories, it’s easy to see why most players at the college and pro levels have made the switch.

Cons of Plastic Sticks

However, plastic sticks are not without their downsides. Here are some of the drawbacks to look out for:

Can Become Brittle Over Time – As plastic sticks age and degrade from use, they can become brittle and prone to snapping.
Less “Feel” Than Wood – Plastic dampens vibration and flex, giving less nuanced feedback on catches, throws, and shots.
Lower Durability Than Hardwoods – Alloys might scratch, chip, or crack with hard slashes and checks.
Harder to Repair – It’s easy to sand down and patch damaged wooden sticks. Repairing plastic often requires replacement parts.
Less Eco-Friendly – Most plastics won’t biodegrade like wood. Composite sticks are difficult to recycle.

While modern plastics offer many performance benefits, they still can’t match the longevity, touch, and feel of natural hardwoods.

Pros of Wooden Sticks

Wood lacrosse sticks have been passed down from generation to generation for centuries, and for good reason. Here are some of the advantages that keep wood popular today:

Superior “Feel” – The responsiveness of wood provides better ball control, snap on passes, and a more nuanced sense of the ball’s impact across the head.
Touch and Craftsmanship – No two wooden sticks are exactly alike. Minor variations in wood grain affect performance in unique ways.
Strength and Durability – Hardwoods like hickory are dense, stiff, and highly damage resistant. Solid wood lasts for decades.
Ease of Repair – Dings and cracks in wood are easily sanded and patched to keep a stick playing like new.
Sustainability – Most wood lacrosse sticks use renewable hardwoods. They are also fully biodegradable.

For players who value history, tradition, touch, and sustainability, wood remains at the top of the game.

Cons of Wooden Sticks

With all their benefits, wooden sticks aren’t flawless. Here are some of the drawbacks to consider:

Inconsistency – The minor variations that give wood “feel” also result in sticks that play slightly differently.
Weather Sensitivity – Wood swells and cracks when exposed to moisture, degrading the stick.
Heavier Weight – High density woods add unnecessary ounce compared to ultra-light alloys.
Limited Colors and Graphics – Customization is largely limited to stringing and dyed leather lace.
High Cost – Handcrafting wooden sticks in the U.S. costs exponentially more than mass production.

While woods like hickory and maple result in stellar performance, they lack some of the consistency, customization, and cost advantages of synthetics.

The Verdict in 2023

When it comes to deciding between plastic and wooden lacrosse sticks in 2023, there’s no universally “right” choice. Much depends on your playing style, preferences, and budget. For players who prioritize cutting-edge materials, consistent performance, cool graphics, and affordability, modern plastic sticks get the nod. But no plastic stick has managed to perfectly emulate the nuanced feel, touch, and craftsmanship of natural hardwoods. For purists who still appreciate the history and artistry of the traditional wooden stick, woods remain unmatched despite their limitations.

Ultimately there’s merit to both approaches. Don’t be afraid to experiment with plastic and wooden sticks until you find the one with the right blend of feel, performance, and durability that fits your game. Whether you land on the latest composite or a handcrafted hickory classic, mastering the fundamentals of precise throwing, catching, and scooping will make you a better player regardless of what material you choose.

Pros of Plastic Sticks

Weather Resistance – Plastic won’t swell, crack, or rot when exposed to moisture like wood can. That means they can withstand all sorts of wet weather conditions and won’t degrade over time.
Consistency – Plastic sticks are factory molded for consistent shape and performance. You know exactly what you’re getting from one stick to the next.
Colors and Designs – With plastic you can get sticks in vibrant colors and cool graphic designs that would be impossible with natural wood.
Affordability – Injection molded plastic sticks are far cheaper to produce at scale than hand-crafted wooden sticks, passing the savings along to players.
Customizability – Plastic heads can be easily customized by adding aftermarket inserts, ramps, or adjusting sidewall stiffness.

With high-end alloy plastic sticks now meeting or exceeding wood in most performance categories, it’s easy to see why most players at the college and pro levels have made the switch.

Cons of Plastic Sticks

However, plastic sticks are not without their downsides. Here are some of the drawbacks to look out for:

Can Become Brittle Over Time – As plastic sticks age and degrade from use, they can become brittle and prone to snapping.
Less “Feel” Than Wood – Plastic dampens vibration and flex, giving less nuanced feedback on catches, throws, and shots.
Lower Durability Than Hardwoods – Alloys might scratch, chip, or crack with hard slashes and checks.
Harder to Repair – It’s easy to sand down and patch damaged wooden sticks. Repairing plastic often requires replacement parts.
Less Eco-Friendly – Most plastics won’t biodegrade like wood. Composite sticks are difficult to recycle.

While modern plastics offer many performance benefits, they still can’t match the longevity, touch, and feel of natural hardwoods.

Pros of Wood Lacrosse Sticks – Natural Feel And Flex

Wood lacrosse sticks have been passed down from generation to generation for centuries, and for good reason. Here are some of the advantages that keep wood popular today:

Superior “Feel” – The responsiveness of wood provides better ball control, snap on passes, and a more nuanced sense of the ball’s impact across the head.
Touch and Craftsmanship – No two wooden sticks are exactly alike. Minor variations in wood grain affect performance in unique ways.
Strength and Durability – Hardwoods like hickory are dense, stiff, and highly damage resistant. Solid wood lasts for decades.
Ease of Repair – Dings and cracks in wood are easily sanded and patched to keep a stick playing like new.
Sustainability – Most wood lacrosse sticks use renewable hardwoods. They are also fully biodegradable.

For players who value history, tradition, touch, and sustainability, wood remains at the top of the game.

Cons of Wooden Sticks

With all their benefits, wooden sticks aren’t flawless. Here are some of the drawbacks to consider:

Inconsistency – The minor variations that give wood “feel” also result in sticks that play slightly differently.
Weather Sensitivity – Wood swells and cracks when exposed to moisture, degrading the stick.
Heavier Weight – High density woods add unnecessary ounce compared to ultra-light alloys.
Limited Colors and Graphics – Customization is largely limited to stringing and dyed leather lace.
High Cost – Handcrafting wooden sticks in the U.S. costs exponentially more than mass production.

While woods like hickory and maple result in stellar performance, they lack some of the consistency, customization, and cost advantages of synthetics.

The Verdict in 2023

Pros of Plastic Sticks

Weather Resistance – Plastic won’t swell, crack, or rot when exposed to moisture like wood can. That means they can withstand all sorts of wet weather conditions and won’t degrade over time.
Consistency – Plastic sticks are factory molded for consistent shape and performance. You know exactly what you’re getting from one stick to the next.
Colors and Designs – With plastic you can get sticks in vibrant colors and cool graphic designs that would be impossible with natural wood.
Affordability – Injection molded plastic sticks are far cheaper to produce at scale than hand-crafted wooden sticks, passing the savings along to players.
Customizability – Plastic heads can be easily customized by adding aftermarket inserts, ramps, or adjusting sidewall stiffness.

With high-end alloy plastic sticks now meeting or exceeding wood in most performance categories, it’s easy to see why most players at the college and pro levels have made the switch.

Cons of Plastic Sticks

However, plastic sticks are not without their downsides. Here are some of the drawbacks to look out for:

Can Become Brittle Over Time – As plastic sticks age and degrade from use, they can become brittle and prone to snapping.
Less “Feel” Than Wood – Plastic dampens vibration and flex, giving less nuanced feedback on catches, throws, and shots.
Lower Durability Than Hardwoods – Alloys might scratch, chip, or crack with hard slashes and checks.
Harder to Repair – It’s easy to sand down and patch damaged wooden sticks. Repairing plastic often requires replacement parts.
Less Eco-Friendly – Most plastics won’t biodegrade like wood. Composite sticks are difficult to recycle.

While modern plastics offer many performance benefits, they still can’t match the longevity, touch, and feel of natural hardwoods.

Pros of Wood Lacrosse Sticks – Natural Feel And Flex

Wood lacrosse sticks have been passed down from generation to generation for centuries, and for good reason. Here are some of the advantages that keep wood popular today:

Superior “Feel” – The responsiveness of wood provides better ball control, snap on passes, and a more nuanced sense of the ball’s impact across the head.
Touch and Craftsmanship – No two wooden sticks are exactly alike. Minor variations in wood grain affect performance in unique ways.
Strength and Durability – Hardwoods like hickory are dense, stiff, and highly damage resistant. Solid wood lasts for decades.
Ease of Repair – Dings and cracks in wood are easily sanded and patched to keep a stick playing like new.
Sustainability – Most wood lacrosse sticks use renewable hardwoods. They are also fully biodegradable.

For players who value history, tradition, touch, and sustainability, wood remains at the top of the game.

Cons Of Wood Sticks – Heavier And Can Warp

With all their benefits, wooden sticks aren’t flawless. Here are some of the drawbacks to consider:

Inconsistency – The minor variations that give wood “feel” also result in sticks that play slightly differently.
Weather Sensitivity – Wood swells and cracks when exposed to moisture, degrading the stick.
Heavier Weight – High density woods add unnecessary ounce compared to ultra-light alloys.
Limited Colors and Graphics – Customization is largely limited to stringing and dyed leather lace.
High Cost – Handcrafting wooden sticks in the U.S. costs exponentially more than mass production.

While woods like hickory and maple result in stellar performance, they lack some of the consistency, customization, and cost advantages of synthetics.

The Verdict in 2023

Pros of Plastic Sticks

Weather Resistance – Plastic won’t swell, crack, or rot when exposed to moisture like wood can. That means they can withstand all sorts of wet weather conditions and won’t degrade over time.
Consistency – Plastic sticks are factory molded for consistent shape and performance. You know exactly what you’re getting from one stick to the next.
Colors and Designs – With plastic you can get sticks in vibrant colors and cool graphic designs that would be impossible with natural wood.
Affordability – Injection molded plastic sticks are far cheaper to produce at scale than hand-crafted wooden sticks, passing the savings along to players.
Customizability – Plastic heads can be easily customized by adding aftermarket inserts, ramps, or adjusting sidewall stiffness.

With high-end alloy plastic sticks now meeting or exceeding wood in most performance categories, it’s easy to see why most players at the college and pro levels have made the switch.

Cons of Plastic Sticks

However, plastic sticks are not without their downsides. Here are some of the drawbacks to look out for:

Can Become Brittle Over Time – As plastic sticks age and degrade from use, they can become brittle and prone to snapping.
Less “Feel” Than Wood – Plastic dampens vibration and flex, giving less nuanced feedback on catches, throws, and shots.
Lower Durability Than Hardwoods – Alloys might scratch, chip, or crack with hard slashes and checks.
Harder to Repair – It’s easy to sand down and patch damaged wooden sticks. Repairing plastic often requires replacement parts.
Less Eco-Friendly – Most plastics won’t biodegrade like wood. Composite sticks are difficult to recycle.

While modern plastics offer many performance benefits, they still can’t match the longevity, touch, and feel of natural hardwoods.

Pros of Wood Lacrosse Sticks – Natural Feel And Flex

Wood lacrosse sticks have been passed down from generation to generation for centuries, and for good reason. Here are some of the advantages that keep wood popular today:

Superior “Feel” – The responsiveness of wood provides better ball control, snap on passes, and a more nuanced sense of the ball’s impact across the head.
Touch and Craftsmanship – No two wooden sticks are exactly alike. Minor variations in wood grain affect performance in unique ways.
Strength and Durability – Hardwoods like hickory are dense, stiff, and highly damage resistant. Solid wood lasts for decades.
Ease of Repair – Dings and cracks in wood are easily sanded and patched to keep a stick playing like new.
Sustainability – Most wood lacrosse sticks use renewable hardwoods. They are also fully biodegradable.

For players who value history, tradition, touch, and sustainability, wood remains at the top of the game.

Cons Of Wood Sticks – Heavier And Can Warp

With all their benefits, wooden sticks aren’t flawless. Here are some of the drawbacks to consider:

Inconsistency – The minor variations that give wood “feel” also result in sticks that play slightly differently.
Weather Sensitivity – Wood swells and cracks when exposed to moisture, degrading the stick.
Heavier Weight – High density woods add unnecessary ounce compared to ultra-light alloys.
Limited Colors and Graphics – Customization is largely limited to stringing and dyed leather lace.
High Cost – Handcrafting wooden sticks in the U.S. costs exponentially more than mass production.

While woods like hickory and maple result in stellar performance, they lack some of the consistency, customization, and cost advantages of synthetics.

Plastic Sticks Ideal For Beginners And Casual Players

Pros of Plastic Sticks

Weather Resistance – Plastic won’t swell, crack, or rot when exposed to moisture like wood can. That means they can withstand all sorts of wet weather conditions and won’t degrade over time.
Consistency – Plastic sticks are factory molded for consistent shape and performance. You know exactly what you’re getting from one stick to the next.
Colors and Designs – With plastic you can get sticks in vibrant colors and cool graphic designs that would be impossible with natural wood.
Affordability – Injection molded plastic sticks are far cheaper to produce at scale than hand-crafted wooden sticks, passing the savings along to players.
Customizability – Plastic heads can be easily customized by adding aftermarket inserts, ramps, or adjusting sidewall stiffness.

With high-end alloy plastic sticks now meeting or exceeding wood in most performance categories, it’s easy to see why most players at the college and pro levels have made the switch.

Cons of Plastic Sticks

However, plastic sticks are not without their downsides. Here are some of the drawbacks to look out for:

Can Become Brittle Over Time – As plastic sticks age and degrade from use, they can become brittle and prone to snapping.
Less “Feel” Than Wood – Plastic dampens vibration and flex, giving less nuanced feedback on catches, throws, and shots.
Lower Durability Than Hardwoods – Alloys might scratch, chip, or crack with hard slashes and checks.
Harder to Repair – It’s easy to sand down and patch damaged wooden sticks. Repairing plastic often requires replacement parts.
Less Eco-Friendly – Most plastics won’t biodegrade like wood. Composite sticks are difficult to recycle.

While modern plastics offer many performance benefits, they still can’t match the longevity, touch, and feel of natural hardwoods.

Pros of Wood Lacrosse Sticks – Natural Feel And Flex

Wood lacrosse sticks have been passed down from generation to generation for centuries, and for good reason. Here are some of the advantages that keep wood popular today:

Superior “Feel” – The responsiveness of wood provides better ball control, snap on passes, and a more nuanced sense of the ball’s impact across the head.
Touch and Craftsmanship – No two wooden sticks are exactly alike. Minor variations in wood grain affect performance in unique ways.
Strength and Durability – Hardwoods like hickory are dense, stiff, and highly damage resistant. Solid wood lasts for decades.
Ease of Repair – Dings and cracks in wood are easily sanded and patched to keep a stick playing like new.
Sustainability – Most wood lacrosse sticks use renewable hardwoods. They are also fully biodegradable.

For players who value history, tradition, touch, and sustainability, wood remains at the top of the game.

Cons Of Wood Sticks – Heavier And Can Warp

With all their benefits, wooden sticks aren’t flawless. Here are some of the drawbacks to consider:

Inconsistency – The minor variations that give wood “feel” also result in sticks that play slightly differently.
Weather Sensitivity – Wood swells and cracks when exposed to moisture, degrading the stick.
Heavier Weight – High density woods add unnecessary ounce compared to ultra-light alloys.
Limited Colors and Graphics – Customization is largely limited to stringing and dyed leather lace.
High Cost – Handcrafting wooden sticks in the U.S. costs exponentially more than mass production.

While woods like hickory and maple result in stellar performance, they lack some of the consistency, customization, and cost advantages of synthetics.

Plastic Sticks Ideal For Beginners And Casual Players

Wood Sticks Preferred By Experienced Players

Pros of Plastic Sticks

Weather Resistance – Plastic won’t swell, crack, or rot when exposed to moisture like wood can. That means they can withstand all sorts of wet weather conditions and won’t degrade over time.
Consistency – Plastic sticks are factory molded for consistent shape and performance. You know exactly what you’re getting from one stick to the next.
Colors and Designs – With plastic you can get sticks in vibrant colors and cool graphic designs that would be impossible with natural wood.
Affordability – Injection molded plastic sticks are far cheaper to produce at scale than hand-crafted wooden sticks, passing the savings along to players.
Customizability – Plastic heads can be easily customized by adding aftermarket inserts, ramps, or adjusting sidewall stiffness.

With high-end alloy plastic sticks now meeting or exceeding wood in most performance categories, it’s easy to see why most players at the college and pro levels have made the switch.

Cons of Plastic Sticks

However, plastic sticks are not without their downsides. Here are some of the drawbacks to look out for:

Can Become Brittle Over Time – As plastic sticks age and degrade from use, they can become brittle and prone to snapping.
Less “Feel” Than Wood – Plastic dampens vibration and flex, giving less nuanced feedback on catches, throws, and shots.
Lower Durability Than Hardwoods – Alloys might scratch, chip, or crack with hard slashes and checks.
Harder to Repair – It’s easy to sand down and patch damaged wooden sticks. Repairing plastic often requires replacement parts.
Less Eco-Friendly – Most plastics won’t biodegrade like wood. Composite sticks are difficult to recycle.

While modern plastics offer many performance benefits, they still can’t match the longevity, touch, and feel of natural hardwoods.

Pros of Wood Lacrosse Sticks – Natural Feel And Flex

Wood lacrosse sticks have been passed down from generation to generation for centuries, and for good reason. Here are some of the advantages that keep wood popular today:

Superior “Feel” – The responsiveness of wood provides better ball control, snap on passes, and a more nuanced sense of the ball’s impact across the head.
Touch and Craftsmanship – No two wooden sticks are exactly alike. Minor variations in wood grain affect performance in unique ways.
Strength and Durability – Hardwoods like hickory are dense, stiff, and highly damage resistant. Solid wood lasts for decades.
Ease of Repair – Dings and cracks in wood are easily sanded and patched to keep a stick playing like new.
Sustainability – Most wood lacrosse sticks use renewable hardwoods. They are also fully biodegradable.

For players who value history, tradition, touch, and sustainability, wood remains at the top of the game.

Cons Of Wood Sticks – Heavier And Can Warp

With all their benefits, wooden sticks aren’t flawless. Here are some of the drawbacks to consider:

Inconsistency – The minor variations that give wood “feel” also result in sticks that play slightly differently.
Weather Sensitivity – Wood swells and cracks when exposed to moisture, degrading the stick.
Heavier Weight – High density woods add unnecessary ounce compared to ultra-light alloys.
Limited Colors and Graphics – Customization is largely limited to stringing and dyed leather lace.
High Cost – Handcrafting wooden sticks in the U.S. costs exponentially more than mass production.

While woods like hickory and maple result in stellar performance, they lack some of the consistency, customization, and cost advantages of synthetics.

Plastic Sticks Ideal For Beginners And Casual Players

Wood Sticks Preferred By Experienced Players

Many NCAA Players Use Composite Or Hybrid Sticks

The debate between plastic and wood lacrosse sticks has raged for years in the lacrosse community. With new technologies and materials coming out all the time, it can be tough to decide which type of stick is truly superior in 2023. There are ardent supporters on both sides, with valid arguments for the benefits of each material.

Many NCAA players these days are opting for composite or hybrid sticks, which offer a blend of the traditional wooden frame with newer synthetic materials. These sticks provide improved durability and consistent performance regardless of weather conditions. The stiff carbon composite construction allows for tremendous power in shooting, while the nylon weave adds an element of flex and finesse.

STX, Maverik, and Warrior all have popular composite stick lines used by top college players. While traditionalists may still prefer an all-wood stick, the consistency and technology offered by composite and hybrid lacrosse sticks make them hard to pass up for elite-level play.

The Case for Wood Lacrosse Sticks

Wood purists argue that you just can’t beat the look, feel, and heritage of a handcrafted wooden stick. Popular wood types include ash, maple, and hickory. Wooden sticks require some “break-in” time, but once seasoned, they offer a personalized feel and touch that synthetic materials cannot replicate.

Wood allows for nuanced flex and pocket formation, creating a “whip” feel on shots that gives seasoned players a sense of control and finesse. The artistry and craftsmanship involved in carving and stringing wooden sticks make them special heirlooms to be cherished. While some may see wood as “old school,” lacrosse traditionalists view wood sticks as an integral part of the sport’s history and culture.

The Case for Plastic Lacrosse Sticks

Plastic lacrosse sticks (usually made with materials like polycarbonate, nylon, and carbon fiber composites) offer unparalleled durability and performance consistency. They don’t bend or deform like wood, so you can count on the exact same feel every time, regardless of weather conditions.

The stiffness of composite materials translates exceptionally well to power and velocity on shots, giving players phenomenal shooting speed and accuracy. Plastic sticks are easier to string consistently and require less “break-in” time than wood. The pocket shape holds its form better over time.

New technologies allow engineers to fine-tune the flex profile along the head and shaft, optimizing handling and shot dynamics. While tradition still has its place, many players prefer the high-tech advantages and competitive edge offered by plastic sticks today.

The Composite Stick “Sweet Spot”

For many players today, the emergence of composite sticks has created the ideal middle ground. Composite sticks combine the traditional wooden handle and iconic lacrosse head shape with the advanced materials and performance engineering offered by synthetics.

Warrior, Maverik, and STX all have popular composite sticks designed for discerning players. The wooden handle allows for a personalized grip and feel, while the composite head provides shooting consistency and all-weather durability. Players get the whippy feel and finesse of wood along with the power and handling of synthetic materials.

Hybrid sticks are also growing in popularity, integrating a composite shaft with a wooden head for unique performance qualities.Composite sticks offer players the best of both worlds. You get the natural look and feel of wood along with the space-age performance of modern plastics and materials technology.

The Verdict: It Depends on Personal Preference

When choosing between wood and plastic lacrosse sticks, there are persuasive arguments on both sides. Much of it comes down to personal preference.

Wooden sticks uphold lacrosse tradition and provide a certain finesse and feel synthetic sticks cannot duplicate. However, plastic sticks offer unrivaled consistency and performance innovations as materials science and engineering continues progressing.

The rise of elite-level composite and hybrid sticks demonstrates that many players want the advantages of both natural wood and space-age synthetics. While the “wood vs. plastic” debate continues, the market provides options to suit each player’s personal style and performance needs in 2023.

Keep an open mind, try out sticks in both categories, and decide which feel and response suits your game best. If you change preferences over time, the versatility of composite and hybrid options can grow with you. The right stick provides an extension of a player’s hand, so choose carefully based on your own priorities as a developing lacrosse athlete.

Testing Stick Flexibility And Stiffness Is Key

The plastic versus wood lacrosse stick debate has been going strong for years. With new technologies constantly emerging, it can be tough for players to decide which stick material is ideal in 2023. There are persuasive arguments on both sides, so testing flexibility and stiffness yourself is key.

Many top NCAA programs are using composite and hybrid sticks, blending wood handles with synthetics. The carbon and nylon construction adds consistent power while retaining some natural whip. Excellence demands versatility, so keeping an open mind is important.

The Allure of Traditional Wood Sticks

For purists, lacrosse is synonymous with wooden sticks. Ash, maple, and hickory impart a classic look and feel. Breaking in a wood stick bonds you to the heritage of the game. The artistry of hand carving and stringing makes woodies true heirlooms.

Proponents argue wood offers unmatched finesse. Once personalized through use, it provides nuanced flex for cradling and shooting touch. Weather doesn’t affect wood like synthetics, and the lack of uniformity creates distinction.

The Consistency of Engineered Plastics

Sticks using space-age materials like polycarbonate, nylon, and carbon fiber composites provide unrivaled durability and reliability. Engineers optimize flex profiles for power and handling. Pocket shape stays uniform over time.

Plastics don’t bend permanently like wood. You get the same consistent feel every game, rain or shine. The stiff construction means maximum ball speed for sizzling shots. While some see plastic as “soulless,” performance speaks for itself.

Why Blends Are Becoming So Popular

For many players today, composite and hybrid sticks offer the best of both worlds. They integratewood handles with composite and nylon heads, blending finesse with power. You get natural looks with high-tech performance.

The wooden grip personalizes feel in your hands, while the engineered head provides all-weather consistency. Shooting power and pocket reliability meet whip and control. With options galore, blends allow you to balance heritage with innovation.

Trying Before Buying Is Critical

When debating wood versus plastic lacrosse sticks, personal testing is a must. With sticks as an extension of your hands, fit and feel are paramount. Take time to experiment with both types yourself before deciding.

Wood and composite sticks vary widely in flex profiles, grip shapes, and shooting dynamics. Try shots and cradling moves to get a sense of control and release. See what jives with your playing style.

While recommendations help, no amount of marketing can replace first-hand testing. Keep an open mind, try an array of sticks, and opt for what clicks. With so many choices today, find the right blend of attributes to elevate your game.

Elements to Consider In Your Evaluation

Here are some key factors to evaluate when testing different stick types:

Flex – How much does the stick bend and “whip” when shooting?
Stiffness – Does the stick provide rigid power or fine-tuned control?
Grip shape – Does the handle contour comfortably to your hands?
Balance – Does it feel evenly weighted or head-heavy/shaft-heavy?
Materials – Do you prefer classic wood or engineered composites?
Pocket – Does it form the way you like through break-in?
Weatherproof – Does humidity/rain impact feel and flex?

By carefully evaluating these elements yourself, you can find your ideal stick for taking your game to the next level.

Trust Your Own Hands, Not Just Hype

With wood and plastic lacrosse sticks, personal testing is irreplaceable. Marketing claims don’t always match real-world performance. Take time to cradle, pass, and shoot before deciding.

Wood offers unmatched finesse for some players. Others thrive on the power and consistency of modern materials. Composite sticks blend these attributes for the best of both.

While the “wood vs. plastic” debate continues, today’s variety allows you to optimize for your needs. By trusting your own hands during evaluation, you can make the right choice to elevate your game in 2023 and beyond.

Proper Stringing Impacts Performance With Any Stick

The plastic or wood lacrosse stick debate continues raging, but proper stringing makes a big impact too. With so many choices now, testing and custom stringing are key for optimal performance.

Blends of materials and stringing styles abound in 2023. Keep an open mind and experiment to find your ideal setup. Excellence demands versatility, so don’t limit yourself to just wood or plastic tradition.

The Allure of Classic Wood Stick Craftsmanship

For purists, wood lacrosse sticks capture the essence of the sport. The meticulous hand carving and stringing of hardwoods like hickory, ash, and maple is an art form. Breaking in a woodie bonds you to the game’s heritage.

Supporters argue wood offers unmatched finesse from nuanced flex and pocket “whip.” The lack of uniformity between wood sticks creates distinction. Synthetics can’t match the classic vibe.

Consistency and Power of Engineered Plastic Materials

Sticks made with space-age plastics like polycarbonate, nylon, and carbon composites provide exceptional durability and reliability. Engineers can optimize flex and performance with precision.

The materials prevent permanent bends and deformity. You get the same consistent feel every game, regardless of weather. The stiffness provides awesome ball speed for blistering shots.

The Importance of Pocket Shape and Stringing

While frame materials matter, proper stringing can make any stick sing. A perfectly contoured pocket magnifies the potential, fine-tuning handling and shot dynamics.

Natural gut pockets impart classic feel on wood frames, while nylon meshes optimize power from composite heads. Hybrid stringing provides the best of both. The options today allow for incredible customization.

Take time to string, experiment, and tweak your pocket for peak performance. A good pocket makes average sticks elite.

Try Before Buying – Feel Is Everything

When evaluating wood versus plastic lacrosse sticks, taking them for a test drive is a must. With sticks functioning as extensions of your hands, comfort and control are paramount.

Wood and composite sticks vary widely in balance, flex profile, and shooting release. Cradle and shoot during evaluations to gauge what clicks with your playing style.

While advice helps, first-hand testing can’t be replaced. Keep an open mind, demo an array of sticks, and choose what feels like an extension of you for optimal performance.

Key Performance Factors to Consider

Here are some key elements to evaluate during stick testing:

Balance – Does it feel evenly weighted or head/shaft-heavy?
Flex Profile – Does it bend smoothly or stiffly during shoots?
Grip Shape – Does the contour fit your hands comfortably?
Pocket Feel – Does it cradle cleanly and release crisply?
Materials – Do you like classic wood or modern composites?
Weatherproof – Does humidity/rain alter the feel?

By carefully assessing these factors, you can identify your ideal setup for domination.

Optimize Performance Through Customization

In the wood versus plastic lacrosse stick debate, optimizing performance through custom stringing and tuning is key. Brand hype alone can’t replace first-hand testing.

Wood provides unparalleled finesse for some players. Others thrive on the power of modern materials. Blends allow you to balance attributes.

While tradition has its place, customization allows you to maximize your strengths. Test, evaluate, and string until you find your high-performance soulmate stick.

Personal Preference Dictates Plastic Vs Wood Choice

The debate between plastic and wood lacrosse sticks has raged for years. With new technologies constantly emerging, personal preference now dictates what works best in 2023.

Composite and hybrid sticks blend synthetics with wood for intriguing new options. Testing different setups yourself is the only way to determine your ideal match.

The Allure of Traditional Wood Stick Craftsmanship

For purists, wood lacrosse sticks represent the soul of the sport. The meticulous hand-carving and stringing of ash, hickory, and maple frames is an art form. Breaking in a woodie bonds you to the heritage.

Supporters argue wood offers unmatched finesse from the nuanced flex and pocket “whip.” The subtle variations between wood sticks add distinction. The classic vibe can’t be duplicated.

Consistency and Power of Engineered Plastics

Sticks utilizing space-age plastics like polycarbonate, nylon, and carbon fiber composites provide exceptional durability and reliability. Engineers optimize flex and performance with precision.

These materials prevent permanent bends or cracks. You get the same consistent feel every game, rain or shine. The stiffness also enables maximum ball speed for sizzling shots.

The Rise of Intriguing Composite Blends

Many players today are opting for composite and hybrid lacrosse sticks, merging wood with synthetics. The wooden grip and iconic head shape blend with advanced materials for unique performance.

The wooden handle provides a personalized feel and finesse, while the composite head offers all-weather consistency and power. Players get the “whip” of wood along with the precision of plastics.