Consider the position you play
Choosing the right softball glove starts with considering the position you play. Infielders need a smaller glove with a shallow pocket to quickly transfer the ball, while outfielders can use a larger glove with a deeper pocket for catching fly balls. As a pitcher, focus on finding a glove with a closed web and sturdy leather to hide your pitching grip.
Infielders
As an infielder, prioritize responsiveness and ball control. Opt for a glove 11.5 to 12.5 inches in size, with a shallow pocket depth around 3 to 4 inches. An open web is ideal to improve visibility while fielding grounders. Models like Wilson A800 or Rawlings Renegade are great choices.
Outfielders
For outfielders, a bigger glove with a deeper pocket helps secure fly balls. Look for gloves from 12.5 up to 13 inches with a 4.5 to 5.5 inch pocket depth. While closed webs are common, open webs can also offer needed visibility on high pop-ups.
Pitchers
Pitchers should choose a glove designed to conceal grips, like models with closed webs and sturdy leather. Opt for 11.5 to 12 inch gloves with deeper pockets around 4 to 5 inches. Popular pitcher’s gloves include Wilson A900 and Rawlings Player Preferred.
Determine your hand size
One key factor in finding the right softball glove is determining your hand size. Measure from the tip of your middle finger to the base of your palm in inches. For youth players, match your hand size to recommended glove sizes. For adult gloves, add 0.5 to 1 inch beyond your hand size.
Youth sizes
For young players, follow these general sizing guidelines based on hand size:
- 6 inches or under – 9 to 10 inch glove
- 6 to 7 inches – 10 to 11 inch glove
- 7 to 8 inches – 11 to 12 inch glove
- 8 inches and over – 12.5 to 13 inch glove
Adult sizes
Adult players should choose a glove .5 to 1 inch larger than their hand size. For example:
- 7 inch hand – 11.5 to 12 inch glove
- 8 inch hand – 12.5 to 13 inch glove
- 9 inch hand – 13 inch glove
Choose the right web type
The web design – either open or closed – is another key factor. Closed webs provide more glove stability and concealment, while open webs allow greater visibility and ball control.
Closed web
Closed webs are a solid piece of leather between the thumb and fingers. They provide maximum pocket depth for securing balls on catches. Pitchers often prefer closed webs to hide their pitching grip.
Open web
Open webs have an open space between the thumb and fingers for increased visibility. Infielders rely on open webs when fielding ground balls, while outfielders use them tracking pop flies.
Modified web
Modified or trap webs have a closed top and partially open bottom for a hybrid design. They aim to provide added visibility while still offering some concealment and stability.
Select the proper size
Along with your position and hand size, the ideal glove size depends partly on your age and skill level. Youth players need smaller gloves to fit their hands, while experienced older players can handle larger glove sizes.
Youth gloves
For young kids under 12 years old, stick with youth sized gloves from 9 to 12.5 inches. Ensure the glove is proportional to their hand size. As they grow, move up to the next size increment.
Adult gloves
Adult female players generally use gloves from 11 to 13 inches. Most adult male players prefer gloves from 12 to 13.5 inches. Larger glove sizes allow experienced players to widen their catching range.
Try different glove designs
Beyond basic size and web differences, softball glove designs can vary in aspects like pocket shape, wrist openings, and finger lacing. Consider your needs for responsiveness, comfort and control.
Pocket design
Shallower pockets improve ball control for infielders, while deeper pockets help outfielders secure fly balls. Pocket shape also varies, from wider curved to narrower v-shaped.
Wrist openings
Narrower wrist openings enhance glove control and security, while wider openings allow for added flexibility and less restriction.
Finger stalls
Individual finger stalls allow for more dexterity and ball control. Some gloves offer open finger designs or just two-finger stalls for faster break-in.
Test different wrist styles
Softball gloves come in closed wrist, dual welting, and open back designs. Trying these different wrist styles can help you find the right balance of adjustability and stability.
Closed wrist
Closed wrist gloves offer a secure fit with maximum structure and support. They provide a snugger feel overall.
Dual welting
Dual welting gloves add a flexible wrist opening for greater adjustability while still maintaining wrist support.
Open back
Open back gloves provide the most flexibility, allowing you to easily slip your hand in and out. However, they sacrifice some stability in the process.
Check the glove’s pocket depth
A glove’s pocket depth impacts catching performance. Shallower pockets allow faster ball transfers for infielders, while deeper pockets help outfielders secure fly balls.
Infield gloves
For infielders look for gloves with pocket depths around 3 to 4 inches, which enhances responsiveness.
Outfield gloves
Outfielders should opt for gloves with pocket depths from 4.5 to 5.5 inches to help snag fly balls and reduce sting.
Look for high-quality leather
The leather quality affects the glove’s durability and performance. Higher quality leather breaks in faster and forms a better pocket.
Full-grain leather
Made from top-grain steer hides, full-grain leather offers superior durability, quality and performance.
Top-grain leather
Top-grain leather removes some imperfections for added softness. It delivers excellent quality at a lower price point.
Other materials
While synthetic blends can save money, they won’t match the quality and performance of full or top grain leather gloves.
Consider break-in time needs
The break-in time for a new glove to feel game ready can vary. Expect higher quality leather gloves to break in faster.
Pre-oiled
Some new gloves come pre-oiled to expedite the break-in process and develop a better pocket.
Ready to use
Higher end gloves made from full-grain leather are often ready for game use with minimal break-in required.
Longer break-in
Cheaper gloves made from synthetic blends or stiff leather require a longer break-in period until ready for game action.
Weigh glove weight preferences
Glove weight ranges based on your position, preference and strength. While heavier gloves offer more protection, lighter gloves allow faster handling.
Youth gloves
For younger players, choose gloves weighing 15 to 24 ounces to prevent fatigue.
Infielder’s gloves
Infielders often prefer lightweight gloves from 11-15 ounces for quick transfers and throws.
Outfielder’s gloves
Outfielders can handle heavier gloves from 15-17 ounces with deeper pockets for catching fly balls.
Review available features
Some gloves include handy features like adjustable wrist straps, padded thumb loops, claw closures and personalization options.
Wrist straps
Adjustable wrist straps customize the fit for optimal comfort and control when handling the glove.
Thumb loops
Padded thumb loops protect your thumb from jams and blows when catching balls.
Claw closure
A claw closure between the thumb and index finger allows for easy opening and closing of the glove.
Personalization
Many manufacturers offer custom name, number and graphic options to personalize your new glove.
Compare brand reputations
Stick to reputable athletic brands known for consistent quality and performance. Some top softball glove manufacturers include:
- Wilson
- Rawlings
- Mizuno
- Louisville Slugger
- Marucci
- Nokona
Set your budget
Softball glove pricing largely depends on factors like materials, quality, features and brand reputation. Be prepared to spend:
- $30-$60: Entry-level youth gloves
- $60-$140: Mid-range adult leather gloves
- $150+: Premium gloves from top brands
Read online reviews
Research softball glove brands and models online. Read user reviews and ratings on sites like:
- Amazon
- Dick’s
- Modell’s
- Scheels
- Manufacturer websites
Focus on feedback related to fit, comfort, quality and durability compared to price. This helps identify the best gloves to consider and avoid poor performers.
Try it on in-store
If possible, head to a sporting goods store and try on some gloves in person. This allows you to test the fit, feel and responsiveness. Bring your softball to try catching with different glove options.
Consider sizing up and down and compare different brands. See what design aspects like the wrist opening, webbing and finger compartments feel most comfortable. Once you find the right glove providing a snug, secure fit, you’re ready to take it out on the field!
Determine your hand size
When looking for the perfect softball glove, one of the most important factors is determining your hand size. You want a glove that is properly fitted to your hand, not too tight or too loose. An ill-fitting glove can negatively impact your performance on the field.
To find your hand size, simply measure from the tip of your middle finger down to the base of your palm. This measurement in inches will help guide you in choosing the right glove size.
Youth glove sizing
For young softball players, use the following general youth glove sizing chart based on hand size:
- 6 inches or under – 9 to 10 inch glove
- 6 to 7 inches – 10 to 11 inch glove
- 7 to 8 inches – 11 to 12 inch glove
- 8 inches and over – 12.5 to 13 inch glove
It’s important to pick a youth glove proportional to the player’s current hand size. As they grow over the seasons, they can size up incrementally to the next glove size.
Adult glove sizing
For adult softball players, take your measured hand size and add .5 to 1 inch to determine your ideal glove size range. For example:
- 7 inch hand – 11.5 to 12 inch glove
- 8 inch hand – 12.5 to 13 inch glove
- 9 inch hand – 13 inch glove
The extra .5 to 1 inch gives a comfortable fit with a little wiggle room for your fingers. A glove that is right on your hand size will typically be too snug.
Also consider factors like your playing position and experience level. Youth and female players can use smaller gloves, while older or male players may opt for larger glove sizes.
Finding your proper hand size is a key first step. This ensures you choose a softball glove tailored to your hand measurements for optimal performance.
Choose the right web type
The design of the web between the thumb and fingers is a key factor when selecting your softball glove. The main options are an open web, closed web, or modified web.
Closed web
A closed web glove has solid leather between the thumb and fingers. This provides maximum pocket depth and stability for securing balls on catches. Pitchers often prefer closed webs to conceal their pitching grip from batters.
Open web
An open web glove leaves an open space between the thumb and fingers. This gives players better visibility and improved ball control on catches, ideal for infielders fielding grounders. Outfielders also use open webs to track pop flies.
Modified web
A modified or trap web combines features of open and closed webs. It has a closed top portion for stability but an open bottom portion for increased visibility. This hybrid web aims to provide both concealment and visibility.
Consider your position and needs when choosing your web type:
- Infielders: Prioritize open webs for better visibility and ball control.
- Outfielders: Open or modified webs allow tracking pop flies while providing pocket depth.
- Pitchers: Closed webs are preferred to hide pitching grips from batters.
Also factor in your experience level. Beginners may want more visibility from an open web to help learning, while advanced players can utilize closed webs for added control and stability.
Trying on different web types is recommended. An open web may feel too unsecure for some, while a closed web could limit visibility too much. Find the right balance of responsiveness and concealment from the web design.
Select the proper size
Choosing the right softball glove size is key to maximizing your performance. The optimal glove size depends on factors like your position, age, hand size, and skill level.
Youth glove sizes
For young players under 12, stick with youth glove sizes ranging from 9 inches up to 12.5 inches. Make sure the glove is proportional to the child’s current hand size. As they grow, move up incrementally to the next size.
Female glove sizes
Most female players do best with glove sizes from 11 inches to 13 inches. Smaller hands can benefit from more control with a smaller glove size in this range.
Male glove sizes
The majority of adult male players prefer gloves sizes between 12 inches and 13.5 inches. Bigger hands can handle these larger glove sizes and maximize catching range.
Infielder sizes
For infielders look for gloves sizes from 11.5 to 12.5 inches. This improves responsiveness and ball control when fielding.
Outfielder sizes
Outfielders can use larger gloves ranging from 12.5 up to 13 inches. The bigger glove with a deeper pocket helps secure fly balls.
Pitcher sizes
Pitchers do well with gloves from 11.5 to 12 inches that allow them to easily conceal their pitching grip and provide stability.
Try on different glove sizes to gauge fit and feel. Consider sizing up or down if a glove feels too loose or snug. The right size should feel secure without restricting movement.
Take your position, age, hand size, and experience into account when selecting the proper softball glove size for optimal performance.
Try different glove designs
Beyond basic size and web type, softball glove designs can vary in aspects like pocket shape, wrist openings, and finger stalls. Testing different designs is recommended to find the ideal balance of comfort, control and responsiveness for your needs.
Pocket design
The shape and depth of the pocket affects glove performance. Shallower pockets improve ball control for infielders, while deeper curved pockets help outfielders secure fly balls. Pocket widths also differ from narrow v-shaped to wider curved shapes.
Wrist opening
The wrist opening impacts flexibility and security. Narrower openings provide a tighter, more controlled fit. Wider openings allow quick hand insertion and removal, but sacrifice some stability.
Finger stalls
Finger stall options range from no stalls for a quicker break-in, two-finger stalls, to full individual finger stalls for optimal dexterity and feel.
Consider the following design factors when choosing your softball glove:
- Infielders: Shallow pocket and open wrist for quick exchanges
- Outfielders: Deeper pocket and closed wrist for security
- Pitchers: Closed pockets and fingers to conceal grip
Also factor in your preference for snugness vs adjustability in the wrist opening. And decide if full finger stalls provide better control for you compared to open finger designs.
By trying gloves with different design elements, you can determine the ideal combination to complement your position, comfort and playing style.
Test different wrist styles
The wrist design of a softball glove impacts the balance of flexibility and control. Testing out different wrist styles can help find your ideal fit and feel.
Closed wrist
Closed wrist gloves provide maximum wrist support and stability. The snug fit gives excellent structure and security, but minimizes adjustability.
Dual welting
Dual welting gloves add flexible openings to allow your wrist to breathe while still maintaining control. This style aims to offer both adjustability and structure.
Open back
Open back gloves maximize flexibility by allowing you to easily slide your hand in and out. However, the looser wrist offers less stability compared to closed wrist options.
Consider your needs when choosing a wrist style:
- Younger players may prefer adjustability from dual welting or open back.
- Players with wrist injuries can benefit from the structure of closed wrist designs.
- Infielders may opt for some flexibility to allow quicker glove exchanges.
Also factor in your experience level. Beginners can utilize the added wrist control from closed styles as they learn, while veterans may want the quick entry/exit of open back gloves.
Try on different wrist styles to gauge comfort and mobility. Closed wrists can feel too restrictive for some, while open backs may seem too loose. Finding your ideal wrist design results in the perfect softball glove fit.
Check the glove’s pocket depth
A glove’s pocket depth – the distance between the palm and outer edge – directly impacts catching ability. The right depth depends on your position and needs.
Shallow pockets
Gloves with shallow pocket depths around 3-4 inches are ideal for infielders. The minimized depth allows faster exchanges and ball control.
Deep pockets
For outfielders, look for gloves with deeper pockets around 4.5-5.5 inches. The extra depth helps secure fly balls while reducing sting.
Position-based needs
- Infielders: Shallow pockets for quick transfers
- Outfielders: Deep pockets to catch fly balls
- Pitchers: Moderate depth to conceal grip
Also consider experience level. Beginners may prefer shallow pockets for more control. Veterans can handle deeper pockets to expand their catching range.
Test gloves with different pocket depths when deciding. Deeper pockets can limit responsiveness for some, while shallow pockets reduce security on catches for others. Find your ideal balance of quickness and catching ease through pocket depth.
Measuring depth
To measure pocket depth, lay the glove flat and measure from the bottom of the palm to the top outer edge using a soft measuring tape. Compare depths across different glove models and brands.
Dialing in the right pocket depth results in a softball glove tailored to your position, skill level, and catching needs.
Look for high-quality leather
The leather quality greatly impacts a glove’s durability and performance. Higher quality leather breaks in faster and forms a better pocket for catching balls.
Full grain leather
Made from top-grain steer hides, full grain leather offers the highest quality and durability. It provides superior shaping for breaking in the glove.
Top grain leather
Top grain leather removes some imperfections from the hide for added softness. It’s an excellent balance of quality and affordability.
Other materials
Synthetic leather blends can save money but won’t match the performance of full or top grain leathers. Prioritize quality leather construction.
Leather grades
Leather grade impacts price, with full grain being the most expensive. But the higher cost brings better durability, pocket formation, and longevity.
Consider the following when choosing leather:
- Youth gloves can utilize lower cost synthetics
- Frequent players need full grain for extended lifespan
- Position players prefer top grain for optimal pockets
Inspect and compare leather quality across glove options. Quality full or top grain leather results in optimal break-in while providing seasons of superior performance.
Consider break-in time needs
New gloves require a break-in period of use before feeling game ready. Higher quality leather gloves tend to break in faster.
Pre-oiled
Some new gloves come pre-oiled to expedite break-in and prime the leather for shaping. This allows faster game readiness.
Ready to use
Top grain leather gloves are often nearly ready for game use right away. They require minimal use to form the pocket shape.
Extended break-in
Lower quality synthetics and stiff, lower cost leathers demand longer break-in periods until the glove feels broken in.
Consider break-in time based on your season timing and leather quality:
- Buy early for extended pre-season break-in
- In-season: Seek pre-oiled or ready to use gloves
- Check reviews for input on break-in duration
Proper break-in uses like playing catch helps the glove conform to your hand and develop optimal pocket depth. Allow time for break-in when purchasing a new glove each season.
Weigh glove weight preferences
Glove weight ranges vary based on position, experience level, and personal preference. Lighter gloves allow faster handling while heavier gloves offer more protection.
Youth glove weights
For younger players, choose lighter youth gloves from 15-24 ounces to prevent hand and arm fatigue.
Infielder’s gloves
Lightweight gloves from 11-15 ounces help infielders quickly transfer and throw the ball.
Outfielder’s gloves
Heavier glove weights from 15-17 ounces help outfielders secure fly balls with the deeper pockets.
Personal preference
Some players simply prefer the feel of a lighter or heavier glove for comfort. Test different weights when trying on gloves.
Consider the following when selecting glove weight:
- Youth players need lighter gloves to avoid fatigue
- Infielders benefit from lighter gloves for quick exchanges
- Bigger players can handle heavier gloves for more protection
Try gloves on with various weight options to find your ideal balance of speed vs. security based on position, experience and personal preference.
Review available features
Some softball gloves include bonus features for added performance, protection, and customization. Useful options to look for include:
Wrist straps
Adjustable wrist straps allow you to customize the tightness for a secure, comfortable fit when breaking in and using the glove.
Thumb loops
Padded thumb loops protect your thumb from jams and blows when catching balls hit right at the glove.
Claw closure
A claw closure between the thumb and index finger makes it easy to open and close the glove quickly when fielding balls.
Personalization
Many glove brands offer custom name, number, and graphic options to personalize the look and feel of your new glove.
Consider your needs when weighing accessory features:
- Adjustability – Seek out wrist straps
- Protection – Opt for thumb loops
- Ease of use – Choose a claw closure
- Style – Personalize with digits and graphics
Bonus features help maximize performance, protection, and comfort when choosing your softball glove.
Compare brand reputations
When choosing a softball glove, stick with reputable athletic brands known for quality and performance. Some top glove manufacturers include:
- Wilson
- Rawlings
- Mizuno
- Louisville Slugger
- Marucci
- Nokona
These companies have proven track records crafting high-quality gloves with excellent fit, feel, durability, and performance.
Material quality
Top brands rely on premium leathers like full grain and top grain steer hides for superior gloves.
Player popularity
Elite players at all levels trust and prefer gloves from major athletic brands.
Craftsmanship
Leading companies have mastered glove construction for optimal shape, pockets, and break-in.
New technologies
Reputable brands innovate with new glove technologies, materials, and features season after season.
While lesser known brands can offer cost savings, opt for an established brand to ensure a high-quality glove with exceptional performance and durability.
Set your budget
Softball glove pricing varies based on factors like materials, quality, features, and brand reputation. Expect to spend:
- $30-$60: Entry-level youth gloves
- $60-$140: Mid-range adult leather gloves
- $150+: Premium gloves from top brands
Set your budget by considering the following:
- Youth: Focus on fit over features
- Occasional players: Seek mid-range durability
- Elite players: Invest in premium quality
Materials cost
Higher quality leathers like full-grain and top-grain boost cost but also improve performance and longevity.
Brand reputation
Well-known athletic brands command a price premium but deliver proven consistency.
Sales timing
Shop off-season sales to maximize value. Prices rise leading up to each new season.
Setting a glove budget helps narrow down options to find your ideal fit, feel and quality at the right price point.
Read online reviews
Research softball glove brands and models online before buying. Browse user reviews and ratings on sites like:
- Amazon
- Dick’s
- Modell’s
- Scheels
- Manufacturer websites
Focus on feedback related to:
- Sizing guidance
- Comfort and feel
- Durability
- Quality of materials
- Value for the price
This helps identify the best gloves for your needs and budget while avoiding poorly rated options.
Common complaints
Look out for consistent complaints about things like:
- Ill-fitting wrist straps
- Stiff, rigid leather
- Lack of pocket depth
- Poor quality lacing
- Durability issues
Online reviews provide insight into real-world performance to help select your ideal softball glove.
Try it on in-store
If possible, visit a sporting goods store to try on gloves in person before buying. This allows you to test the fit, feel, and responsiveness.
Sizing
Bring your hand measurements and try sizes above and below your measurement range. Gauge overall fit and finger room.
Brands
Compare different brands side-by-side. Note differences in wrist flexibility, padding, and overall comfort.
Materials
Assess leather quality and suppleness. Synthetics may feel cheaper and less responsive.
Webs
Examine visibility and ease of closure between open, closed, and modified web types.
Catching
Bring your softball and mimic catching motions. Test control, security, and pocket depth.
Trying gloves on in-store helps narrow down your ideal fit, feel, design and brand before purchasing. Once you find a snug, responsive glove that feels like an extension of your hand, you’re ready for the field!